EPL Matchday 5 Best Bets: Top Predictions for Weekend Action

profile image of David Manyun
West Ham United's German defender Thilo Kehrer (L) and West Ham United's Italian defender Angelo Ogbonna celebrate on June 7, 2023. MICHAL CIZEK / AFP.

Best Premier League Matchday 5 Bets:

Soccer Pick: West Ham-Manchester City Both Teams to Score (-140) at BetOnline (visit our BetOnline Review)

BetOnline logo
Both Teams to Score (-140)
Visit Site

Soccer Pick: Newcastle-Brentford Both Teams to Score (-133) at Everygame (visit our Everygame Review)

Everygame logo
Both Teams to Score (-133)
Visit Site

We’ve studied the EPL betting markets to formulate the best betting picks for this weekend’s fixtures involving West Ham vs. Manchester City, Newcastle United vs. Brentford, and more.

Continue reading for this weekend’s top soccer betting picks from across the Premier League fixtures set to take place on September 16 & 17, as chosen by leading offshore sportsbooks.

West Ham United FC vs. Manchester City


  • When: Saturday, Sept. 16, 2023 – 10:00 AM EDT
  • Where: London Stadium
  • EPL Win/Loss Record (2023/24): West Ham W/W/W/D – Manchester City W/W/W/W

Stats, Odds, & Prediction

  • Man. City has conceded at least 1 goal in 3 of their previous 4 games.
  • West Ham has scored 12 goals in their previous 6 games in all competitions.
  • Both teams have scored in West Ham’s last 6 games in all competitions.


A Battle at the Summit

Growing pains in the absence of their former star Declan Rice were expected for West Ham United, and a 1-1 draw with Bournemouth on matchday 1 of the season was evidence of this. However, emphatically, the Hammers have run through the competition since and are now riding a three-game win streak – netting 8 goals during this stretch.

To the delight of West Londoners, overcoming their capital rivals Chelsea (3-1) was a quick reminder that the game isn’t a one-man show. And with or without Rice, the Hammers are capable of a Champions League placement this season, especially after watching Newcastle, Brighton, and Villa achieve European placements last term.

Holding the Crown

Pep Guardiola and his Manchester City unit have achieved nothing out of the ordinary thus far. Through four Premier League matchdays, they’ve collected all 12 points possible and are undoubtedly a threat to West Ham’s undefeated record as they tightly hold onto the EPL crown.

Before the international break, Erling Haaland was doing Erling Haaland things. He bagged a brace in City’s 5-1 demolishing of Fulham, as he and the blue side of Manny look as dominant as ever.

EPL Matchday 5 Betting Odds & Predictions

Unsurprisingly, the Premier League odds have made Manchester City the favorite. Still, with two in-form squads with unbeaten records going head-to-head, our betting prediction shouldn’t be as black and white as the numbers suggest.

Between these two squads, we’ve witnessed a combined 20 goals in the EPL this term. Manchester City has kept just one clean sheet in their previous four games in all competitions, and West Ham has seen over 3.5 goals in three consecutive games. All signs point towards both teams scoring, especially with the underdogs holding a home-pitch advantage.

Score Prediction: West Ham United 2 – 2 Manchester City

The Pick

Soccer Pick: Both Teams to Score (-140) at BetOnline [1.40u wager returns 1u of profit]

Newcastle United FC vs. Brentford London FC


  • When: Saturday, Sept. 16, 2023 – 12:30 PM EDT
  • Where: St. James’ Park
  • EPL Win/Loss Record (2023/24): Newcastle L/L/L/D – Brentford D/D/W/D

Stats, Odds, & Prediction

  • Both teams scored in both EPL games between Newcastle and Brentford last season.
  • Brentford has seen both teams have scored in 3 of their 4 EPL games this term.


A Miserable Beginning

The international break couldn’t have come at a better time for Newcastle United, a team that’s lost 3 of their 4 domestic meetings this season and have looked a shell of their former selves compared to last year’s success.

The Magpies defied all expectations during the 2022/23 season and finished in fourth position. Still, as they prepare for their first Champions League campaign since 2002, domestic results for Eddie Howe’s men have resulted in misery.

With that said, visits to Manchester City and Brighton alongside a home meeting with a refreshed Liverpool hasn’t been a kind schedule, and they did lose all of those fixtures by a mere 1-goal deficit.

Cannot Pull the Trigger

Brentford was another overlooked team of last season that surprisingly finished in the top half of the table, but much like their weekend opponents, they’ve failed to find fifth gear this term and have been plagued with three draws in their four opening matches.

Recent results suggest Brentford could struggle for three points yet again as they travel up north on Saturday. Even so, finding the net shouldn’t be an issue for this team that’s scored at least one goal in all four of their EPL meetings this season so far.

EPL Matchday 5 Betting Odds & Predictions

The betting odds have placed Newcastle as a slight moneyline favorite despite their recent downtrend. However, backing both teams to score for a respectable price of -133 seems like the safest approach.

Both teams have scored in 3 of Brentford’s 4 EPL meetings this term, and this trend is identical to Newcastle’s outings, too. Each team found the net at least once in both EPL meetings last term, and we expect similar defensive frailties to surface this weekend.

Score Prediction: Newcastle United 1 – 3 Brentford London

The Pick

Soccer Pick: Both Teams to Score (-133) at Everygame [1.33u wager returns 1u of profit]

Extra Premier League Bets to Beat the Bookie

  • AFC Bournemouth vs. Chelsea FC

Soccer Pick: Chelsea FC (-130) at Bovada (visit our Bovada Review)

Bovada logo
Chelsea FC (-130)
Visit Site

  • Everton FC vs. Arsenal FC 

Soccer Pick: Arsenal FC (-185) at Heritage Sports (visit our Heritage Sports Review)

Heritage Sports logo
Arsenal FC (-185)
Visit Site

*The line and/or odds on picks in this article might have moved since the content was commissioned. For updated line movements, visit BMR’s free betting odds product.