2026 NFL Draft Long Shots: 7 Props Paying +500 or Better Worth a Small Ticket
There’s nothing more fun than sweating a longshot bet that cashes in. Maybe you got lucky, or maybe you read between the lines and connected the dots on a prop that others overlooked. However you attain your big payday, it’s sure to be rewarding.
There’s a litany of information surrounding the NFL Draft, and by the time we get within a few days of the opening round, some would-be surprises have already been spoiled. That doesn’t mean there aren’t still opportunities to cash in on some big NFL Draft bets, though.
With odds from some of the best offshore sportsbooks, we’re taking a look at seven NFL Draft props with long odds – in this case, +500 or better – that may have a better chance of winning than bookmakers believe.
Best 2026 NFL Draft Longshot Bets
All odds are current as of Monday, April 20. Associated NFL draft sportsbooks mentioned in copy.
Position of Mr. Irrelevant: Running Back (+600)
Let’s be real: Does anyone really know who the last player drafted will be? There’s little, if any consensus this far down the board, meaning you’ll often find different picks in every mock draft. Team needs can provide some insight, but even then, it has to be a fairly minor need considering they waited this long to address it.
With that in mind, Mr. Irrelevant is a good place to start for longshot bettors. At BetOnline, you’ll get odds under +450 for defensive line, wide receiver and offensive lineman – these are extremely common draft positions, after all – and +600 and above beginning with running back.
Running back is one of the most least valued positions in the NFL Draft these days. It’s much easier to find value in the later rounds. The Broncos are making this pick, and they’re thought to be in the market for depth at the position. Perhaps a boom-or-bust prospect like Jaydn Ott could be the move here?
Denver has three seventh-round picks, and it’s plausible that it uses at least one of those on a running back. Other options here include cornerback (+700), linebacker (+800) and safety (+1100).
Team to Draft Jordyn Tyson: New York Jets (+700)
The New York Giants are currently the betting favorites to select Jordyn Tyson, presumably with the No. 10 pick they acquired from the Cincinnati Bengals. The team’s general manager reportedly ate dinner with Tyson last week, so the connection exists.
There are a few other wide receivers available in that range, though – including Makai Lemon – who could easily wind up going to the Giants. Should that be the case, the Jets would be among the first in line to snag Tyson at No. 16.
This prop comes down to how thin of a line these franchises believe exists between Tyson and Lemon. Carnell Tate is widely expected to be the first receiver drafted, but it gets murky from there. Big boards and mocks both vary on draft position
The Jets have the fifth highest odds to draft Tyson, per BetOnline. The Giants are the favorites at (+200), followed by the Saints (+300), Chiefs (+500) and Commanders (+550).
Team to Draft Kenyon Sadiq: Los Angeles Rams (+600)
Sadiq is one of the most intriguing players in this draft class. Widely regarded as the top tight end available, the Oregon product is an unreal athlete who dramatically boosted his stock at the NFL Draft Combine. Standing 6-foot-3 and weighing 240 pounds, he ran a 4.39 40-yard dash and posted a 43.5-inch vertical jump, among other ridiculous numbers.
The Buccaneers and Panthers are thought to be the most likely destinations in the 15-19 range, but the Rams could also be in play for a stud tight end at No. 13. There’s certainly no denying that Matthew Stafford would make the most of such a target, and Los Angeles’ system would work in Sadiq’s favor.
BetOnline has this pick at +500, but you can get it at Bovada at +600. Remember to always check competing sportsbooks to find the best odds.
No. 4 Overall Pick: Arvell Reese (+850)
The Jets are projected to select Reese with the No. 2 pick, but there’s a real debate on whether it’ll be him or David Bailey. New York is known to be interested in both players, and while Reese has the higher ceiling, there’s an argument to be made that Bailey’s proven production and pro-ready style would make him the better pick.
Adam Schefter reports that there’s a real connection between Jeremiyah Love and the Arizona Cardinals at No. 3, so there’s certainly a reality in which Reese is still available at No. 4. However, it seems unlikely that he would slide any further, especially since Robert Saleh is now calling the shots for the Tennessee Titans.
CBS insider Jonathan Jones has one of the many mock drafts with Bailey going second and Reese fourth. Bovada has this bet available at +850.
To be Drafted in First Round: Caleb Banks (+700)
Florida defensive tackle Caleb Banks is a monster of a man. Standing 6-foot-6 and weighing over 325 pounds, he’s considered to be one of the top defensive lineman in his class. He’s a first-round talent, but an injury-shortened campaign in 2025 has him going in the second in some mocks.
With that said, there are plenty of teams in the back half of the first round that could use an upgrade at the position, including the Chargers (No. 22), 49ers (No. 27) and Patriots (No. 31). That puts Banks right on the fringe, but Bovada’s +700 seems like a stretch.
Ultimately, it seems like his draft position may come down to how concerned teams are about his injury history. If any are willing to overlook his past, they could be getting one of the most talented defensive linemen available.
Pittsburgh Steelers Position of First Drafted Player: Defensive Line/EDGE (+900)
The Steelers did just draft a defensive lineman with their first pick in the 2025 NFL Draft, but that’s not all this pick buys us. Edge rushers are included here too, and that’s where the value is – especially with rumors swirling about Pittsburgh trading Alex Highsmith.
If the Steelers are looking to build around their youth and get some cap flexibility, an edge rusher could be in the cards at No. 21. That range could include players like Keldric Faulk, Akheem Mesidor, T.J. Parker and Cashius Howell, among others.
There would be no shortage of options available should Pittsburgh elect to lean into its defensive identity and grab another edge rusher. BetOnline has this as the Steelers’ fifth most likely option behind offensive lineman (+150), wide receiver (+175), quarterback (+700) and safety (+800).
Washington Commanders Position of First Drafted Player: Defensive Line/EDGE (+600)
Washington is another team that could be looking to improve its pass rush. The Commanders had a down year after making a surprise run to the NFC Championship in 2024, finishing 5-12 and struggling to overcome injuries to Jayden Daniels. The defense ranked 27th.
Like Pittsburgh, Washington should have a decent selection of edge rushers available when it picks at No. 7. David Bailey could still be there (although it’s unlikely), and Rueben Bain Jr. may well be the best player available when the Commanders are on the clock.
BetOnline lists wide receiver (+150) and running back (+225) as more likely options, but edge rusher, linebacker (+600) and safety (+600) are all tied for third. If you believe Washington goes defense, this is a great spot to look.
Final Thoughts
Sports bettors know there’s no such thing as a sure thing, and chaos often takes over the NFL Draft. Now is the perfect time to connect the dots from various insider reports and seek out longshots that could become favorites in a matter of hours.
To find the best odds and deepest markets, look no further than our list of the best offshore sportsbooks. There are endless ways to bet on the NFL Draft, and these betting sites give you plenty of freedom in how you go about it.
