Skip to content

Opinions on MLB merging Negro league with MLB

Archie

Archie

Joined
Nov 8, 2021
Messages
10,324
josh gibson will now surpass raul Ibanez for the coveted #276 on the all time list of HRs. I will not pick him. but rather the guy he passed and is now #277
 

djefferis

djefferis

Joined
Jan 8, 2024
Messages
4,678
Stats are just that - statistics.

People need to understand just because you hit a higher average - doesn’t mean all factors are equal. Hell - I'd take Ted Williams over most hitters if I needed a hit to win the game - statistically not the greatest - but to the eye test - he is to me.

Some guys were great - but will always be slightly “overrated” based on stats. Most people understand that these players weren’t playing against the absolute best every day - but they were playing against guys of major league talent and excelled. Was Satchel Paige the best pitcher ever - not to me…but neither was Nolan Ryan. Both put up good numbers thanks to long careers and have their fan bases.
 

Archie

Archie

Joined
Nov 8, 2021
Messages
10,324
we NEED Hoss Radbourne to travel in time and come humble today's hitters.

tell me Hoss ain't an all time great
 

Archie

Archie

Joined
Nov 8, 2021
Messages
10,324
fucker threw 73 complete games one year
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot_20240529-171418.png
    Screenshot_20240529-171418.png
    702.8 KB · Views: 2
Last edited:

BigJay

BigJay

Joined
Oct 28, 2021
Messages
28,661
Josh Gibson is now listed as the all time leader in batting average over ty cobb.
 

BigJay

BigJay

Joined
Oct 28, 2021
Messages
28,661
Stats are just that - statistics.

People need to understand just because you hit a higher average - doesn’t mean all factors are equal. Hell - I'd take Ted Williams over most hitters if I needed a hit to win the game - statistically not the greatest - but to the eye test - he is to me.

Some guys were great - but will always be slightly “overrated” based on stats. Most people understand that these players weren’t playing against the absolute best every day - but they were playing against guys of major league talent and excelled. Was Satchel Paige the best pitcher ever - not to me…but neither was Nolan Ryan. Both put up good numbers thanks to long careers and have their fan bases.
One thing you always have to take into account stats-wise when talking about Williams and folks in his era is he missed four years plus in the absolute prime of his career due to WWII. Was an ace pilot.

Love Ted Williams. There was a great bio on him, HBO maybe. I wish I could find it again.
 

djefferis

djefferis

Joined
Jan 8, 2024
Messages
4,678
True - a lot of guys missed out due to WW2

Oddly - you never hear how guys who were too old for the war effort or didn’t participate for whatever reason “padded” their stats not playing against all the greats who were away. Same for those in negro leagues in this era.

Williams was so much more than a baseball player - military hero, legendary outdoorsman and supposedly one hell of a marksman with a rifle. He was a man’s man in an era when that type of thing wasn’t frowned upon by society.
 

BigJay

BigJay

Joined
Oct 28, 2021
Messages
28,661
True - a lot of guys missed out due to WW2

Oddly - you never hear how guys who were too old for the war effort or didn’t participate for whatever reason “padded” their stats not playing against all the greats who were away. Same for those in negro leagues in this era.

Williams was so much more than a baseball player - military hero, legendary outdoorsman and supposedly one hell of a marksman with a rifle. He was a man’s man in an era when that type of thing wasn’t frowned upon by society.
Funny. I was going to use the term man’s man in my post but got lazy.

And yes, they focused on all of the above in the documentary on him.

1717026196203.jpeg
 

Archie

Archie

Joined
Nov 8, 2021
Messages
10,324
Cap Anson rolling over in his grave
 

Archie

Archie

Joined
Nov 8, 2021
Messages
10,324
Did the Negro leagues play 158 games per season ? More or less should be an *

some of the first pro seasons included in current stats were underhand and under 80 games.

asterisks could be everywhere.

how about asterisks for the bare hand days too?

it's numbers, who gives a fuk
 
Top