The race for the next Mayor of New York City is already heating up, and it’s not just politics enthusiasts paying attention. Bookmakers Review has compiled the latest odds from BetOnline, giving bettors an early chance to size up the field at the best offshore sportsbooks available.
What makes this even more intriguing is that these markets aren’t available everywhere, as BetOnline is one of the very few sportsbooks actually offering odds on who will become NYC’s next mayor. That exclusivity makes this a rare opportunity for political bettors looking to get in on the action before the campaign trail really kicks into gear.
Will it be a familiar face like Andrew Cuomo, or a progressive rising star like Zohran Mamdani who captures the city’s top job? The early odds tell the story.
Cuomo vs Mamdani Betting Odds
Let’s take a look at the latest betting odds for the New York mayoral race, courtesy of BetOnline as of Tuesday, September 16:
- Zohran Mamdani (-600)
- Andrew Cuomo (+350)
- Eric Adams (+10000)
- Curtis Sliwa (+10000)
The numbers show just how lopsided the market looks right now. Zohran Mamdani stands out as the overwhelming favorite at -600, signaling strong confidence from oddsmakers that he’ll take the mayor’s office. Andrew Cuomo, meanwhile, sits at +350, keeping him firmly in the mix but clearly behind the frontrunner.
Current Mayor Eric Adams and perennial candidate Curtis Sliwa round out the board at long-shot odds of +10000, reflecting the steep uphill battle they face in this race.
Cuomo vs Mamdani: Next NYC Mayor?
Two very different figures top the board for the next New York City mayoral race in Andrew Cuomo and Zohran Mamdani, and the contrast between them couldn’t be sharper.
Cuomo is a household name in New York politics. The former three-term governor still has strong recognition, deep donor networks, and loyal supporters who see him as a steady hand in city leadership. But Cuomo also carries significant baggage from his controversial resignation in 2021, and his return to the spotlight would be polarizing at best. While his +350 odds suggest there’s a path, bettors should weigh whether voters are ready to embrace his comeback.
Mamdani, on the other hand, represents a new wave of progressive politics in the city. A state assemblyman from Queens, Mamdani has built a reputation as a grassroots organizer and a champion for housing justice, working-class issues, and immigrant communities. His coalition mirrors the same energy that powered Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez into Congress, making him a formidable favorite in a city that leans heavily progressive.
That’s why oddsmakers have Mamdani priced as the clear frontrunner at -600. Yes, the number is juiced and not ideal for value hunters, but in this case the chalk makes sense. Mamdani’s profile fits the city’s current political climate, while Cuomo’s road back to power looks far less likely. If you’re looking to make a wager, Mamdani is the right side, even if you’ll need to risk more up front to secure a smaller return.
How to Bet on the New York Mayoral Race
Betting on the next mayor of New York City is an easy process. Just follow these steps:
- Create a username and password at BetOnline.
- Click the menu sidebar to open up betting markets.
- Navigate to “Politics” and then “Mayoral Races.”
- Tap the mayoral candidate to add it to your bet slip.
- Determine how much money you want to wager.
- Hit “Place Bet” to complete the process.
Do note that you have until the day of the election, which is November 4th, 2025, to bet on the New York mayoral race.
Read our BetOnline hands-on review for more information about what this betting site has to offer.
