Best NBA Playoffs Player Prop Bets Today (May 9)

profile image of Matthew.Jordan

Both Milwaukee and Golden State look to take 3-1 series leads in their respective playoff series vs. Boston and Memphis, respectively, on Monday night. Here are two player prop picks on each matchup with odds from BetOnline (visit our BetOnline Review), one of BMR’s top-rated sportsbooks.

Boston Celtics vs. Milwaukee Bucks

Monday, May 9, 2022 – 07:30 PM EDT at Fiserv Forum 

Jrue Holiday 

Have to say that I didn’t expect the Bucks to win this series without injured All-Star Khris Middleton and maybe they won’t, but they lead 2-1. We all know how spectacular Giannis Antetokounmpo is, and he had 42 points, 12 rebounds, and eight assists in the 103-101 victory in Game 3 on Saturday.  

The guy who has really stepped up in Middleton’s absence has been point guard Jrue Holiday. In the five-game first-round win over Chicago, he averaged 16.4 ppg. In this series, he’s averaging 23.0 points, 6.7 rebounds, and 5.0 assists. He scored with 11.2 seconds left for a 103-100 lead in Game 3.

Join Now: $1,000 BMR 12-Week All Sports Challenge

Holiday remains a stellar defender as guys he has guarded are hitting just 30.6 percent, the lowest by any defender in these playoffs.  

Meanwhile, I wonder if having to guard Giannis is starting to wear down Celtics All-Star Jayson Tatum, who also injured his wrist on a dunk in Game 3: "It's something I've been dealing with for probably like two months now. It wasn't anything abnormal, when I fall on it, it bothers me, but nothing that I haven't been dealing with the last couple of months." 

NBA Pick: Holiday Over 33.5 Points + Rebounds + Assists (-107) at BetOnline 

BetOnline logo
Holiday Over 33.5 Points + Rebounds + Assists (-107)
Visit Site

Jayson Tatum

Tatum really struggled in hitting 4-for-19 from the field for 10 points. He finished 0-for-10 when Wesley Matthews was the primary defender on him. Only three of Tatum’s shots came within five feet of the basket. Coach Ime Udoka said Tatum was overthinking things and getting too deep into the Bucks’ defense: 

“He was passing up some open looks, overthinking at times. Just gotta try to simplify it, not get too complicated. They’re gonna sit back in the lane, you’ll have your pull-ups. And like I said after the first timeout, one or two dribbles too many. Kind of getting into the teeth of your defense.

We gotta set screens and free these guys up and they can walk into their wide-open shots. Over penetrated a little bit, got into the crowd a little bit, and started overthinking a little bit.” 

While I’m sure Tatum won’t be held to 10 points again, that 28.5-point number is massively high. 

NBA Pick: Tatum Under 28.5 Points (-120 ) at BetOnline 

BetOnline logo
Tatum Under 28.5 Points (-120)
Visit Site

Memphis Grizzlies vs. Golden State Warriors

Monday, May 9, 2022 – 10:00 PM EDT at Chase Center 

Klay Thompson 

The big news for this matchup is that Memphis star Ja Morant is not expected to play after suffering a knee injury in the fourth quarter of Game 3 on Saturday. Jordan Poole grabbed that knee but said he is "not even that type of player" to try to intentionally hurt someone.

He and Andrew Wiggins trapped Morant near half-court before Wiggins was called for a foul with 6:55 left. Poole will not be disciplined by the league.  

"It was a basketball play when we doubled him," Poole said. "And I hit the ball, and I was going for the ball. I mean, obviously, you don't want to see anybody get hurt. I'm not even that type of player. I respect everybody." 

Coach Taylor Jenkins said Sunday that “there is probably a really good chance (Morant) doesn't play.” Thus, I give the Grizzlies almost no chance on Monday even though they were 20-5 without Morant during the regular season. His expected absence has jumped the NBA odds to Dubs -10. 

NBA Pick: Thompson Under 21.5 Points (-112) at BetOnline 

Thompson Under 21.5 Points (-112)
Visit Site

Tyus Jones  

Because there isn’t 100 percent certainty on Morant yet, the books are holding off on props for other Grizzlies players. I believe that they will list Tyus Jones at over/under 5.5 assists. He’s one of the best backup point guards in the NBA, will start in Morant’s place, and actually has led the league four straight seasons in assist-to-turnover ratio – the only other player to lead that category in four seasons is Chris Paul.

Jones’ 7.03 ratio this year was the best in league history. He’s not really a scorer so I think he exceeds 5.5 assists fairly easily because he’s going to play mega-minutes. 

Golden State was unconscious from the field in the 142-112 victory in Game 3, shooting 63.1 percent and with a true shooting percentage of 76.1 percent, both second-best in a playoff game in league history. Klay Thompson had been shooting 28.9 percent from the floor in the first two games but was 8-for-13 on Saturday.  

Check Out Our Video Section: Today’s Picks of the Day

“When we're getting good shots, the chances of Klay getting hot are much greater," Warriors head coach Steve Kerr said. "And when he gets hot our team takes on a different look. ... So it's all connected." 

I think Thompson’s point total is too high … plus, don’t rule out the fact this could be a blowout again and Thompson doesn’t play heavy minutes. 

NBA Pick: Jones Over 5.5 Assists (TBA) at BetOnline

BetOnline logo
Jones Over 5.5 Assists (TBA)
Visit Site

*The line and/or odds on picks in this article might have moved since the content was commissioned. For updated line movements, visit BMR’s free betting odds product.